The Community

ROCK AND ROLL! => All Them Other Guys => Topic started by: Billy Underdog on April 21, 2018, 04:29:00 AM

Title: Overplayed classics
Post by: Billy Underdog on April 21, 2018, 04:29:00 AM
A thread meant to have a second view and review of great tunes that've been ruined by being played too much, to understand there's a reason they're overplayed in the first place. Because they're damn good. And there's more than Paranoid, Smoke On The Water and Stairway To Heaven...

My first contribution:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDOL7iY8kfo
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Tyr66 on April 21, 2018, 05:37:23 AM
- Breaking the Law and Living after Midnight .
Two classics of the band, although very average compositions especially the second. LAM looks like an commercial for some chewing gums brand.
I just can not hear 3 notes of each anymore.

- Highway To Hell . great song but really overplayed . Still works when we hear the entire album.
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Billy Underdog on April 21, 2018, 06:06:14 AM
^^^ Great pickings!

As for JP, BtL is the better tune of the two. A through&through Heavy Metal Classic which in many ways define a whole genre in one single "hit". LAM is more a Pop Hard Rock gem, and understandibly the bigger hit in a mainstream casual audiences viewpoint. Can't stand it, love it  :))

HtH.. goddamned...

I never put any of these on myself any longer, but if they suddenly come up at a party or on the radio...
If any of these tunes doesn't put you in a good-time hard Rockin' party-mood, there's seriously something wrong with you.  :rockon: :beerbang:
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Tyr66 on April 21, 2018, 06:32:31 AM
You really got Me , covered by Van Halen.

Strangely, Jump still works. This intro and sound of keys typically 80s so catchy , these few seconds waiting for the moment when Alex attacks his so recognizable beat.

Ah ! another one : Empty Rooms by Gary Moore , except for the live version of We Want Moore, of course.
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Tyr66 on April 21, 2018, 06:39:58 AM
Enter Sandman, or when the Met 'rip off AC/DC.
So tiring from the 5th listening ...  and the counter has more than 10,000 today .
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Billy Underdog on April 21, 2018, 12:13:31 PM
You really got Me , covered by Van Halen.

Disagreed. Luckily i was a fan of Kinks before i even heard VH, so i've got no other than bad relations to them doing that cover, and hence it's never been overplayed either. Rather shut off as fast as possible, such blasphemy...

Enter Sandman; what a fucking great tune from a craftsmanships perspective. THE perfect Metal hit at the very end of Metals most successful era as part of the mainstream Pop music, killing Glam while also giving way to the "new" Metal harking back to classic Metal (that is Groove and Grunge, NOT Nu-Metal...).
I have to say i hear more a Sabbath rip-off than AC/DC rip-off, though, but i think/guess your point was more about that "going back to classics" thing?

Nontheless, because of this and the Thrash vote i'm going to treat myself with the Black Album right now.

Already well into Sad But True as i'm typing this. HEAVY!!!
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Charger on April 21, 2018, 12:30:10 PM
I was just gonna say Sad But True...man that gets played to death on radio rock....and it's a pretty weak song too...

Ace Of Spades comes to mind...a killer track but everytime when it's Motörhead it's always Ace Of Spades...

Actually Highway To Hell isn't the most played AC/DC song here...that'd be TNT...another great song but waaaaay too much air time.

Kiss' I Was Made For Loving You gets played a lot too...and I don't really like Kiss to begin with....

Gonna throw in one more Ozzy's Crazy Train....it's not even close to being the best one on Blizzard and it's the only one that ever gets played...

Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Billy Underdog on April 21, 2018, 01:36:09 PM

Ace Of Spades comes to mind...a killer track but everytime when it's Motörhead it's always Ace Of Spades...


With good reasons. Try to explain "Dirt-Rock/Metal" to an alien; play them Ace Of Spades... :rockon:
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: KiloDeltaCharlie on April 21, 2018, 04:39:20 PM
I can't stand Layla by Derek and the Dominoes anymore... that whiny guitar solo at the end is just like finger nails dragged down the blackboard to my ears.

And then there is Bohemian Rhapsody... love the song but I can't bear to hear it broadcast unless there is a good reason such as the "greatest rock tracks of all time top 10 run down".

Another Brick in the Wall... yes it was a big hit single... yes it is *quite* good... but why play this when Floyd have done so much better!



Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Tyr66 on April 22, 2018, 03:10:00 AM
And then there is Bohemian Rhapsody... love the song but I can't bear to hear it broadcast unless there is a good reason such as the "greatest rock tracks of all time top 10 run down".


true.
mainstream news radios broadcast play it from time to time. Tired and often out of place.
the worst is that our Rock culture is so poor that they still confuse Queen and Freddy Mercury when they announce which title has just been played, often cut before the end. Without laughing.

Off topic but in the same vein, the "specialist" of the only live music show announced Adrian Vandenberg and his new band by proclaiming just before they start playing : "and please welcome the one who played with Ritchie Blackmore ". I saw a short but heavy moment of loneliness in Adrian's eyes ...
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Tyr66 on April 22, 2018, 05:19:02 AM

Ace Of Spades comes to mind...a killer track but everytime when it's Motörhead it's always Ace Of Spades...


With good reasons. Try to explain "Dirt-Rock/Metal" to an alien; play them Ace Of Spades... :rockon:

Overkill ?
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Zzzptm on April 22, 2018, 08:06:45 AM
There are about 1000 songs or so in the Classic Rock repertoire, I've seen a few "Top 1000" lists, and every Top 100 list pulls from those tunes.

And every time, EVERY TIME "China Grove" rolls around, it's a party. :rockon:

EVERY DAMN TIME! :batdance:

It's that opening CHUCKA-DOW-WOWWW CHUCKA-DOW-WOWWW CHUCKA-DAT DAT-DAT DAT-DAT riff that drives the whole song, all the way to the end, save for that pretty little bridge in the middle that has a party all its own going on.
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Billy Underdog on April 22, 2018, 08:07:39 AM

Ace Of Spades comes to mind...a killer track but everytime when it's Motörhead it's always Ace Of Spades...


With good reasons. Try to explain "Dirt-Rock/Metal" to an alien; play them Ace Of Spades... :rockon:

Overkill ?

Sure. Not as overplayed, though.
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Zzzptm on April 22, 2018, 08:14:27 AM
Another one that shows up all the time that really doesn't ever get overplayed is Jethro Tull's masterwork, "Living in the Past." The opening flute solo that sets up the handoff to the vocals is sheer brilliance. I'll never skip tunes or switch stations if that rolls around on the Classic Rock 1000.
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Billy Underdog on April 22, 2018, 08:53:08 AM
^^^ That's the first one mentioned i might actually put on myself every now and then, not just enjoy when it suddenly comes along. I don't think it's even possible to actually overplay it either... :)
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Vyn on April 22, 2018, 05:40:52 PM
Agree with Layla being overplayed. For decades. In fact, there's not much Clapton I can stand anymore, regardless of the guise he wore. Except Cream.

Which brings up Only You Know and I Know. Dave Mason was cool Delaney and Bonnie were cool, but damned if Clapton didn't stick his fingers in it and make them all sound like a bunch of drunks wailing around a bonfire.

Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Zzzptm on April 22, 2018, 07:42:54 PM
Stuff from Fleetwood Mac's Rumors album gets played all the time, but "The Chain" is one that I love each time I hear it. Top Gear voted it one of the ten best songs to drive to, and I agree with that assessment.
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Zzzptm on May 02, 2018, 03:47:46 PM
Three Dog Night - "Shambala"

Play that on eternal repeat, I don't care. I love that song.
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Billy Underdog on September 20, 2018, 10:40:19 AM
Ok, it's time... What a riff, what a guitar sound, what an attitude. What a tune!  :D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUwEIt9ez7M  :rockon:
Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Vyn on September 20, 2018, 11:24:35 AM
I had to inspect the source code of the page in order to determine that you posted a link to Smoke On the Water.

Fitting, actually, given all of the hidden meanings and obscure references in that song. Combined with the complex musical layers and textures that song is the eternal "pick your own meaning" song.

Oh, I'm sorry, I was thinking of:

Title: Re: Overplayed classics
Post by: Zzzptm on September 20, 2018, 12:45:14 PM
"I'm making a movie trailer and I need music for it."
"Is there any money in the movie?"
"Yes, there's a scene where the kid collects money for mowing his neighbor's yard."
"THEN PLAY THIS SONG!"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXE_n2q08Yw

^ Except this is the album version, which is *not* the one used for soundtracks, etc. They go to the single edit. The full album version is great, especially when it's taken in context with the rest of the Ship Ahoy album.